All Reviews
Nathan Hale
2 weeks agoTraveling from another state looking for a spot that had an outside area we could take our dog also. This was the spot. Great food and service!
Cullen Rice
3 months agoThis pizza spot never disappoints! The crust is perfectly baked with a satisfying crunch, and the sauce has a rich, balanced flavor. Toppings are fresh, plentiful, and taste amazing in every bite. Orders are always ready on time and served hot. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it a great place to relax and enjoy a delicious meal with family or friends.
Casey Watson
4 months agoBrothers Pizza was absolutely amazing!! Our colleges equestrian team was in town for a show and we found them because they were close to our hotel, they were so sweet and even gave us a complimentary tray of cinnamon dough bites that were OUT OF THIS WORLD!!
Brad Barritt
Edited 5 months agoStopped in Lamar due to snow driving home. Looking for some good local food other than fast food. It was New Year's Eve, and the hotel staff suggested Brother's Pizza. Ordered a white pizza with garlic knots. It was a terrific NY style slice in PA. The owner Manny delivered in snowy conditions and was beyond friendly. If you're looking for good local food, this is your place.
lily j
7 months agoI ordered a Hawaiian pizza and it was delicious! It was snowing outside, and while I was waiting in my car, one of the staff kindly brought out my freshly made pizza — so warm and thoughtful! They also gave great recommendations when I was ordering. Excellent service and tasty pizza!
Glenn S.
a year agoThe sandwich breads are all homemade and AMAZING, light and almost like biscuits. "Small meatball sub" special was 4 open face sandwiches, delicious. Onion rings thick, freshly fried, and tender. Jalapeño burger came with jalapeños and cheese grilled to the top and bottom bun, and a big smash burger type burger. Oh, free garlic and herb coated dinner rolls with red sauce to start! Friendly folks. Owner came out personally to check on us and others. Huge menu, I bet everything is great!
el cholabels page 1
3 years agoAs I pulled in I noticed it was a family restaurant. I didn't know what to order but ask for a menu. I seen on the menu they have calzone so I got a small regular and a regular drink. I notice a small child I ask if he was working and he pointed at his sister no she is which made me laugh 😂. He was just there in the midst of it all. The calzone was very delicious and cheesy. Just the way it should be prepared. The food was not overpriced and the service was great. Anyone from out of town should check this place out and enjoy a great lunch at brother's pizza. Let them know you seen my review.
Vie C
3 years agoRoadtrip from Boston to Chicago, searching for a good dinner place as traditional fast food wasn’t appetizing. Looked up places near the area we were passing by and Brothers Pizza of Lamar came up. Reviews were great & took the chance. SOOO GLAD WE DID!! Ordered sausage pizza and order of cheese fries. Some of the best NY style pizza I’ve had. Sauce - homemade, fresh and flavorful but not overwhelming. Crust- not thick nor thin, perfect chewiness with a good bite and crisp on the edges. Fries were heavenly… crispy outside with tender/mash potato inside. Received some garlic knots— pillowy soft and freshly made. Staff was super friendly, homey vibe made us feel comfortable while eating. Will be our must-go stop on our next road trip to NE. Thank you for a great meal and awesome experience.